Season24@30.
People often refer
to episode 1’s notorious cliffhanger but rarely the way its resolved which must
surely rank as one of the most awkward. Somehow Glitz gets down to a ledge that
was not there previously when we saw the Doctor’s feet dangling above a
precipice. If Glitz managed to do that, why didn’t the Doctor use the easier
route? Then the Doctor has to clamber down his mate in the most ungainly
fashion. Combined with the clearly plastic `ice` that surrounds them it’s hard
to imagine that even back in 1987 anyone was impressed.
The three part
format seems to fit this period of the programme quite well allowing this
episode to become more than the runaround it might initially look to be. One
surprise is the amount of time spent with Kane and his helpers Belasz and Kracauer.
While Ian Briggs’ dialogue does tend to
include a bit too much exposition of things both characters in the conversation
would already know it is a different take to have the antagonist’s subordinates
actively plotting against him. Not that Kracauer’s methods are very sound-
having turned up the heat he just stands there and watches instead of hiding
somewhere warm. Then when Kane gets up Kracauer still just stands there.
Kane’s
backstory –revealed in a large info dump from the `dragon` - explains his ice
statue yet we never learn who the bearded sculpter is. Has he really been
toiling over the ice sculpture for years as Kane implies? Does he never get
time off for a shave? A decent ice sculpture can actually be done within a day or
two so he’s obviously been spreading out the work perhaps knowing what would
happen when he finished. The funniest thing is we get to see an image of Xana later
and she looks nothing like the sculpture whose resemblance to his beloved is
something Kane has earlier rhapsodised about! Still Edward Peel draws from
classic Doctor Who villainy in a
controlled performance with appropriate icy menace and you have to enjoy Patricia
Quinn’s Belazs even if she tends to over play some scenes. Incidentally (or
not) several of the characters seem to have an Eastern European flavour to
their names.
Briggs chooses
not to go into much detail about how, having been exiled to the planet, Kane
built up – if indeed he did- a whole society here including shops and utilities.
There is no reference to his chilly biology and whether this is natural for his
species- if so why do none of the others like Belazs – have the same condition?
I do think some light make up of frosting on his face might have worked better
to show his difference though it’s all a bit odd when none of the other
characters shows any reaction to the sub zero environment in which he lives. It
wouldn’t matter so much where it not for the emphasis this episode places on
Kane’s need for a cold environment. Also you might wonder why Kane’s captors
would even put the Dragonfire on the same planet at all? Why not store it
somewhere else entirely?
The camaraderie
between the Doctor and Glitz and Mel and Ace works well this week. Sylvester
McCoy is in excellent form – of all the aspects of this season that have surprised
me his performance has done so the most. There is so much subtlety in between
the more outward clowning and I love his musings to himself, his acceptance
when things aren’t going well and his curiosity. In a quieter scene with Mel,
Sophie Aldred tones down Ace’s enthusiasm with a well written speech on the
character’s background. It is so well written in fact that I feel as if it
would have been good to have seen it. Ace doesn’t get a proper introductory
story back in her normal life despite that potential. The idea of someone who
always believed she was from another world is a great spin on the companion
idea.
My other
favourite scene is the Doctor’s philosophical talk with a guard which superbly
counters expectations that the latter would look bewildered by the question;
instead he engages with it. This sort of thing would become more prevalent in
the following two seasons and suits this Doctor. It’s also in the tradition of
the programme where words played a big part in some of the best written stories
of the 70s.
Again there’s a
bit of a naff cliffhanger though – in this case Kane declaring “Dragonfire will
be mine” even though to the viewer it’s probably not clear what it does and
what difference that would make. In any case surely that crystal will literally
be too hot for Kane to handle?
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.